Software review lectures (slideshow in PDF format, 63K)
Author: PMT left Reef
From:
http://www.pmtsolution.net/forums/pmtforumum004-20020512.pdf
Review definition Review (IEEE STD 1028-1988) IS An Evaluation of Software Element Or Project Status to Ascertain Discrepancies from Planned Results and To Recommend Improvement.
The review is an assessment means of software elements or project status to determine if it is consistent with the results of the plan and makes it improved.
Classification of reviews Generally, the review (Walkthough) is a paer deskcheck, a special inspection (PEER DESKCHECK), special inspection (AD) (AD) special inspection (PEER REEER " Hoc Review)
Differences between judges (1) Differences between judges (2) Select the correct evaluation method review in the misunderstanding (1) misunderstanding 1: Review participants do not understand the review process
If the evaluation participant does not understand the entire review process, there will be a natural resistance to emotions, because everyone can't see the effect of this matter, feel confused, this will seriously affect the enthusiasm of everyone to participate in the review. Misunderstanding in the review (2) Misunderstanding 2: Reviewer Review Developers, not products
The main purpose of the review is to discover problems in the product rather than evaluating the level of developers based on products. However, there will often be something to link product quality and development personnel, so the "taste" has become "taste", which has become a "battalion conference", which greatly combats the self-esteem of developers, and even seriously affects the effect of the review .
The misunderstanding of the review (3) Misunderstanding: The review is not arranged to enter the project plan
Participating in reviews requires a lot of time and effort, and should be arranged to enter the project plan. However, the situation of reality is often, and the review has become "volunteers", and those who participate in the review must work overtime to complete the review task. As a result, the reviewers do not understand the review objects.
Misunderstanding in the review (4) Misunderstanding 4: The review meeting became a problem solution discussion
The main purpose of the review meeting is to discover problems, rather than solving problems, and the solution to the problem is what you need to do after the review meeting. However, due to the pursuit of technicians, the review meeting tends to become a problem seminar, a large number of reviews of the review meeting, resulting in a large number of review contents to be ignored, leaving countless hidden dangers. The misunderstanding of the review (5) Misunderstanding 5: The reviewers did not know enough about the review materials in advance
Any review material is the crystallization of others, and it takes enough time to understand, familiar with and think. Only in this way can we find valuable deep levels at the review meeting. In many reviews, reviewers did not understand the review materials before the review meeting, and there was a strange phenomenon that the review meeting became a technical report before the review meeting.
Misunderstandings in the review (6) Six: Reviewers pay attention to non-qualitative issues
Such problems often occur, in the review, too much reviewers focus on some non-qualitative issues, such as document format, wording, rather than product design. Such a situation, there is a possible reason: there is no choice of appropriate people to participate in the review; the reviewers do not know enough about the subjects and cannot find a deep problem. Misunderstand in the review (7) Misunderstanding: ignore detail
Many people don't pay attention to details during the process of organizing review. For example, the meeting time setting, notice of the meeting, the selection of conference venues, the arrangement of the venue environment, the provision of conference facilities, the adjustment and control of the atmosphere at the meeting, and this details will greatly affect the results of the review meeting. For example, it is hard to imagine that everyone can put in the conference room that is cloudy and a large noise.
